Build Me Up Buttercup Butter Tarts

Hi there,

lush filling cradled by a flaky crust

I think there’s nothing more Canadian than a lush Butter Tart.  Sure, there’s Tarte au Sucre, Maple Syrup Pie, and Nanaimo Bars, just to name a few…however, because this is my blog, I can be biased and declare Butter Tarts as the representative of Canadian dessert pride (tee-hee).  Butter tarts are reminiscent of a pecan pie –sans the pecans.

The Crust Rim= perfect for breaking off and dunking into filling

As a veteran butter tart eater, I shall give you the lowdown on these addictive sweets.  I’ve found that there are three camps people can fall into regarding filling preference: oozy and runny, custardy soft and quivery-set, or firm with a slight yield. Typically, I fall in the middle of the camp.  I enjoy this soft filling because I find it the creamiest.  I also like the middle of the road butter tart for tehnical reasons.  When you crack it open, the filling will remain within the walls of the crust. For neater eating’s sake, it sure beats a runny, messy filling that, more often than not, lands on your clothing than in your tummy.

Butter Tart!

There is definitely a method involved to making butter tarts; in addition, one must be concerned about the proper crust to filling ratio.  Since the gooey innards are so intensely buttery-sweet, to me, the crust must not have any sugar, be flaky and light, but sturdy enough to cradle the filling, once it is set.

Lastly, there is the contentious issue of whether a butter tart should contain dried fruits in it, namely currents or raisins.  I’m a butter tart purist so I typically forgo these dried up grapes, but by all means, you can add some for textural variance (about 1/2 cup should be adequate.  Just make sure they are plump and moist before you add them to the filling.  If they are dry and crusty, add enough boiling water (in a bowl)  to cover them and leave it for 15 minutes.  Drain the liquid and then proceed with the recipe.

While the ingredients may be quite basic and it appears to be a straightforward recipe– be forewardned that looks are deceiving.

the perfect crust to filling ration in my humble opinion

My eating strategy: I usually take the  rim of the crust and use it as my spoon to pick up all the golden goodness.

When you serve these to guests, I recommend dolloping the tarts with some creme fraiche on top.  The tang tempers the richness of this dessert  perfectly.

This recipe was adapted from Anna Olson.

Glistening, creamy, and delicious butter tart filling

Eh? Butter Tarts!



2 1/4 cups pastry flour

1/2 tsp table salt

3/4 cup lard or vegetable shortening (lard is best but if you don’t have any on hand veg shortening will do)

1 tsp lemon juice (or white vinegar)

1  large egg

4-6 tbsp ice cold water


1/3 cup  unsalted butter, room temperature

1/2 cup dark brown sugar, packed

2 large eggs

1 tsp vanilla extract

1/2 tsp white vinegar

dash cinnamon

pinch of salt

1/3 cup golden corn syrup

1/2 cup + 2 tbsp pure maple syrup (I like to use a medium to dark amber grade over the light stuff… it gives the maple flavour more oomph)


Preheat oven to 375° F.

For pastry, combine flour and salt and cut in lard until coarse and crumbly. Whisk lemon juice and egg and mix into dough until it just comes together. If needed, add 4-6 tablespoons of cold water to help bind the pastry. Wrap and keep at room temperature while preparing filling.

For filling, cream together butter and sugar and stir in eggs. Mix in vanilla, vinegar, cinnamon, salt. Whisk in corn syrup and maple syrup.

On a lightly floured surface, roll out pastry to just shy of ¼-inch thick. Cut 6-inch rounds from pastry and line ungreased muffin tins, pressing in to ensure pastry gets into corners. Pour filling 1/2 way up.  Bake tarts for 18 to 22 minutes, until filling is set. Allow to cool before removing from tin.

Butter tarts will keep up to a week in an airtight container (if they last that long).

Yield: 8

4 thoughts on “Build Me Up Buttercup Butter Tarts

  1. Wow, I have a ton of family in Canada and have visited many times over the years, but I have never heard of a butter tart! My family’s been holding out on me! These look delicious!

    1. Hi Jackie,

      Next time you visit your family in Canada, urge them to bake up a batch of delectable butter tarts with you!

      Cheers and Happy Baking,

      p.s. I highly recommend using a Canadian Maple Syrup for the filling 🙂

    1. Hi Anu,

      I would suggest Lyle’s Golden Syrup or Brown Rice Syrup as a substitute. Or, you could try honey, but it would overshadow the maple syrup.

      Hope this helps!
      Cheers and Happy Baking,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s